In the spirit of this St. Patrick’s Day, also an excellent meal to prepare anytime – I thought I’d share how they did it in the old days… which is how most recipes I’ve seen still advise to do it today.
My great grand parents emigrated from Ireland by way of England, stopping off there for a few years of farming before sailing the pond and setting up a farm in Western Michigan.
I have the old family Bible, published in 1852 – 9″ thick version complete with a few hundred unprinted pages bound in the back for noting family events. Here is where I found this corned beef and cabbage recipe that appears to be written in my great grandmother’s handwriting (with Gaelic slants) .
She calls for a ‘stout’ 6 quart cast iron dutch oven, but any large pot will do. And a 4″ thick center cut of brined brisket – I use a 5-7 lb flat cut; nice portions for six to enjoy.
5-7 lb brined brisket
1 Large head of cabbage
1 lb of carrots
3 large parsnips
2 lbs of potatoes – scrubbed, not peeled (Russets, Idaho’s, Redskins; they all work)
Place the corned beef in a 6 qt pot, add just enough water to cover the top of the meat, bring to a boil, reduce heat, cover and simmer for 3 hours. As you reduce the heat, add the seasoning packet that comes with the corned beef – pretty much the same spices she has listed in the recipe – but add a few extra cranks of fresh ground pepper.
Cut cabbage in to 8 equal wedges – peel and cut carrots and parsnips to 1 inch pieces, cut to potatoes in quarters – place each in separate bowls to await cooking.
Remove corned beef from the pot after 3 hours – fork should pierce through easy, but meat should have enough integrity left to not fall apart (and don’t dump out the water), place meat on platter and cover with a thick dry towel (they didn’t invent foil yet).
Bring cooking water back to a boil, add carrots and parsnips – boil hard for 10 minutes – add potatoes, boil for 5 minutes, add cabbage wedges, cover and boil for 10 minutes more or until you can pierce the cabbage with a fork easily and the outside leaves are still bright green (the issue here is not to boil the vegetables to mush) – remove from stove and set pot on a trivet on the counter – using a slotted spoon, remove vegetables to a large serving bowl.
Slice the corned beef, place slices in the pot water for 5 minutes to moisten again and warm – remove slices to a large platter and take the meat and vegetable bowl to the table.
Serve with white or cider vinegar on the side to splash on the vegetables.
That’s it – simple one pot meal that is about as nutritious and flavorful as you can get.

